The historical past of Disney’s Tune of the South is one in all cheer, racism, and the odd option to construct an amusement park experience primarily based on a movie generations have by no means seen, or ever will. The movie is one full of blended messages, going down in a time after slavery had been abolished, however nonetheless depicting black individuals as subservient to the white. The intense, enjoyable animated characters that harbor a racist subtext, and infrequently an outright proclamation of racism. It is a darkish second within the historical past of Disney, and one which poses a query about whether or not the movie, or any a part of the movie, is salvageable in any manner.
‘Tune of the South’: What’s it About?
Picture by way of Disney
The American Civil Warfare has ended, and 7-year-old Johnny (Bobby Driscoll) has gone to go to his grandmother’s plantation in Georgia. Solely it is not a go to: his mother and father are separating, and he’ll be dwelling on the plantation along with his mom and grandmother. The reality is distressing for Johnny, and he leaves to make the journey to his father in Atlanta, sneaking out at evening. As he sneaks away, he hears outdated Uncle Remus (James Baskett) recount folktales about Br’er Rabbit (Johnny Lee). Intrigued, Johnny listens in however is quickly found by Remus, who tells him a story about how Br’er Rabbit sought to run away, however modified his thoughts after assembly up with Br’er Fox (James Baskett) and Br’er Bear (Nick Stewart).
COLLIDER VIDEO OF THE DAY
RELATED: ‘Splash Mountain’ Trip Completely Closes at Disney World
The story modifications Johnny’s thoughts about leaving, and Remus escorts the boy again dwelling. Different occasions that Johnny will get as much as spur new tales about Br’er Rabbit from Uncle Remus, teachable moments that he takes to coronary heart. Sadly, his mom’s misunderstanding of Uncle Remus’ intentions results in Remus leaving the plantation, however as he does Johnny runs after him and is gored by a bull. Holding on to life, Johnny calls out for Uncle Remus, who’s escorted again in. Remus tells one other Br’er Rabbit story, and Johnny survives his ordeal. The movie ends with Uncle Remus, Johnny, and two different youngsters becoming a member of Br’er Rabbit and pals on a stroll into the sundown, singing the Oscar-winning “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah.”
‘Tune of the South’: Controversial from the Begin
The movie relies on the Uncle Remus tales written by Joel Chandler Harris, a white man who was a Black rights activist. His works current a hard dichotomy, nevertheless. Harris preserved African American folklore, however how he interpreted his characters was racist. Walt Disney purchased the rights to Harris’ Uncle Remus tales in 1939, and went about initiating manufacturing on a movie. He employed Southern-born Dalton Reymond to draft a script, and he submitted one in 1944. That authentic script was offensive to Blacks, a lot in order that the Manufacturing Code Administration (enforcers of the Hays Code) strongly recommended altering components of the script, together with substituting “outdated man” for “outdated darkie,” and “Marse Jawn” switched out for “Mister John.” One PCA ask was deemed a precedence: it needed to be made clear that the movie takes place after the Civil Warfare, after the abolishment of slavery (Disney, nevertheless, did no such factor with the movie, taking away the one factor that will have deflected the criticism hurled towards it). To assist make revisions, Disney employed an African American, Clarence Muse, as a marketing consultant. He pushed for the Black characters to be portrayed in a optimistic gentle, however the response to his ideas had been so unhealthy that Muse resigned earlier than the script was completed.
‘Tune of the South’: No Higher After Launch
With the timeframe of the movie left imprecise, many assumed that it occurred within the pre-Civil Warfare slave period, which wasn’t helped with African People onscreen fortunately engaged on the plantation, or by Uncle Remus being instructed to go away by Johnny’s mom, and never given an opportunity to clarify his aspect of the story. Even the animated sequences had been problematic, with Br’er Rabbit, Br’er Fox and Br’er Bear’s speech made “Black,” and one sequence particularly that made use of a Tar Child to lure Br’er Rabbit right into a lure. The depiction of the movie’s African People drew the ire of the Nationwide Affiliation for the Development of Coloured Individuals (NAACP), who referred to as it a “dangerously glorified image of slavery”, whereas the Nationwide Negro Congress noticed Tune of the South as “an insult to the Negro individuals as a result of it makes use of offensive dialect; it portrays the Negro as a low, inferior servant; it glorifies slavery.” Regardless of the controversy, the movie was profitable in its preliminary launch and re-releases in 1956,1972, 1980, and 1986.
‘Tune of the South’: The Legacy
Picture by way of Disney
New life was given to the movie with the opening of Disneyland’s Splash Mountain, a water log experience, in 1989. The experience had prospects floating by way of animatronic scenes taken from the animated parts of the movie as “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah” performs within the background (assume “It is a Small World” experience, solely with a greater music). It was an odd determination given the controversy the movie had garnered over time, however Disney officers went on report as saying they “didn’t anticipate the experience to impress criticism as a result of it makes use of solely the animated animal characters.” But its racist roots had been sufficient to see the attraction shut-down in January 2023, to be revamped with a The Princess and the Frog theme and renamed Tiana’s Bayou Journey. The one different notable reference to the movie is a fleeting glimpse of the animated characters in 1988’s Who Framed Roger Rabbit.
In any other case, other than pirated copies of the movie you may decide up for those who attempt (Collider strongly advises towards such illicit exercise), the movie is, for all intents and functions, useless. Disney government chairman Bob Iger confirmed that the movie won’t ever be launched to Disney+, even with the “outdated cultural depictions” disclaimer that accompanies movies like Dumbo and Peter Pan. The one piece of the movie that’s salvageable is the Oscar-winning earworm “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah,” a pleasant, cheerful tune when taken out of the context of the movie. Maybe it may discover life with one other Disney property, associating it with one thing far much less controversial as its hyperlink to Tune of the South regularly fades away. Whether or not that may be a viable proposition, although, rests solely on the general public’s willingness to permit it, and with the movie nonetheless producing consideration, because of items like this one. it’s unlikely to occur any time quickly.