A nine-mile journey from the airport in Dhaka, the bustling capital of Bangladesh, to Justice Shahabuddin Ahmed Park, close to downtown, can take so long as 55 minutes, in line with Google Maps.
A visit of the identical distance in Flint, Michigan, from the airport to the Sloan Museum of Discovery, takes about 9 minutes.
Whereas we’d count on a slower drive in a metropolitan space of 20 million vs. a regional metropolis of simply 400,000, the distinction in journey time isn’t due simply to site visitors or congestion, in line with a brand new examine that measures site visitors velocity around the globe. Even at midnight, with few vehicles on the street, the journey in Dhaka—the slowest metropolis on this planet—remains to be half-hour, or thrice so long as the journey in Flint, the world’s quickest.
Based on the examine, revealed as a working paper by the Nationwide Bureau of Financial Analysis, the velocity of journey in a metropolis is barely partially associated to the quantity of site visitors on its roads. Different components, such because the format and high quality of a metropolis’s roads and pure obstacles like hills and rivers, play a major position in how briskly vehicles can drive. Consequently, the examine’s authors make a distinction between journey velocity, a measure unaffected by site visitors, and congestion, which is the interplay of velocity and site visitors.
“The slowest cities aren’t essentially probably the most congested, and most congested aren’t the slowest,” says Prottoy Akbar, an economist at Aalto College in Finland and the lead creator of the paper.
Akbar and his fellow researchers used knowledge from Google Maps to research site visitors in additional than 1,000 world cities with populations over 300,000. Their knowledge set excluded China and South Korea, as a result of the app can’t acquire knowledge in these international locations, whereas just a few different cities, like Pyongyang, North Korea, had been dropped due to unreliable knowledge. They devised consultant journeys vacationers would soak up these cities—a commute from downtown to residential neighborhoods, for instance, and or journeys alongside the periphery from a house to a restaurant—and in 2019 ran thousands and thousands of journeys on the app, at totally different occasions of day and week. In India, for instance, they collected knowledge for 66 million journeys; within the U.S. it was 57 million.
After crunching all that knowledge, they discovered the largest predictor of journey time in any given metropolis isn’t the scale or age of town, however the wealth of the nation through which it’s situated.
The quickest cities, in line with the paper, are nearly all mid-sized municipalities within the U.S.—like Flint, Memphis, and Wichita, Kans.—the place highways are broad and plentiful. Of the 100 quickest cities on this planet, 86 are within the U.S., together with 19 of the highest 20 (the exception is Windsor, Ontario, throughout the Canadian border from Detroit). Even comparatively poor cities in rich international locations are quick.
The slowest cities, like Dhaka, Lagos, and Manila, are nearly all within the creating world the place infrastructure hasn’t stored up with inhabitants.
“All cities with the quickest velocity or uncongested velocity are in wealthy international locations, and all of the slowest cities are in poor international locations,” the authors write.
Congestion, nonetheless, is much less easy. Probably the most congested cities come from a variety of wealthy, poor, and middle-income cities, and whereas they embrace city facilities within the creating world like Bogata and Mexico Metropolis, additionally they embrace New York Metropolis and London. What all of them have in widespread is dimension: very massive cities, unsurprisingly, have extra vehicles on the street.
However it’s additionally attainable to be a congested metropolis with comparatively quick journey velocity, Akbar says. Nashville, Austin, Tampa, Houston, and Atlanta are among the many 25% most congested cities on this planet, however are all within the high 10% for journey time.
A significant takeaway from the examine, Akbar says, is that totally different cities want totally different prescriptions to enhance journey occasions. In Dhaka, the place Akbar grew up, the municipal authorities spent numerous vitality making an attempt to scale back the numbers of vehicles on the street, regulating issues just like the hours eating places might be open and banning slower automobiles like bicycle rickshaws from highways. However “that simply implies that you possibly can, at greatest, make the speeds in the midst of the day seem like speeds in the midst of the night time,” he mentioned. “These type of changes can solely assist up to now.”
Usually, Akbar says, metropolis planners in creating international locations will depend on site visitors research commissioned for cities in international locations just like the U.S. and France, the place the wants and options could also be a lot totally different.
He additionally notes that quick journey doesn’t essentially make a metropolis extra enticing or fascinating, and it might be a results of over-investment in infrastructure relative to its wants. Flint, the quickest metropolis on this planet, has misplaced half of its inhabitants since 1950. “The quickest metropolis on this planet isn’t town to envy,” he says.
Extra Should-Reads From TIME